A Hindu, a Christian, a Muslim, and a Jew – really?

Onde se critica o universalismo religioso moderno inspirado em Gandhi: é logicamente impossível todas as religiões serem caminhos iguais à verdade espiritual. Com C.S. Lewis, defende-se a exclusividade cristã, rejeita-se a não-violência absoluta e enfatizam-se raízes históricas e culturais.

I have told you that I am a Bhangi, a Christian, a Muslim, besides of course being a Hindu.

– Mahatma Gandhi

The quote which constitutes the epigraph that heads these brief reflections, as well as other similar remarks made by Gandhi, was what prompted me to write this. My focus is not so much Gandhi’s Sanatanism, of which I am largely ignorant, but the way religious universalism keeps growing in its appeal – principally in the West – beyond all the bounds of human reason. Clearly, one of the marks of a modern world made growingly insipid by vague and lukewarm conceptions of tolerance, is the equal embrace of all religions as being – equally – paths to spiritual truth. Of course, many now see spiritual truth as whatever is achieved by ideas and practices such as mindfulness, which consists not only in a watered-down version of traditional Buddhist practices, but in a distortion of them – a westernised, secularised version of actual Buddhist mindfulness, sati. In the West, it is now almost a clinical term, something to do merely with mental health, and entirely different from the ascetic reality of those truly steeped in Buddhist thought and ritual.

To begin, however, I should make another digression (and I apologise in advance if the following paragraphs resemble too much the jazz improvisations that stray from the main motif but somehow always make it back, then often fragmenting or rhythmically displacing the motif itself). Well, to put it shortly, Gandhi himself, whom I have quoted, seemed indifferent to biblical typology. His hermeneutical approach is strange, to say the least, very selective (for how can you make things compatible which are not compatible, unless you prioritise certain passages that can, at least if interpreted in some ways, align with your own personal view of things?), and of course quite alien to Christian teaching. Universalist religious thinking has had disastrous consequences. For instance, to claim you admire Jesus Christ because He was a great moral teacher, or a martyr, or one among a myriad of divine beings, while rejecting His unique status as actually God and as part of the Holy Trinity as the Son, is absurd. Christ can only be considered a relevant moral teacher if He is accepted to be the sole incarnation of God, that after which all of us spiritually thirst. No sane man who is not God would tell his followers, ‘Whoso eateth of my flesh, and drinketh my blood, hath eternal life; and I will raise him up at the last day’ (John 6:54). And this claim is not the result of fully reasoned argument, either – it is a claim made by someone who is Truth, not someone who merely possesses it. Socrates was a great moral teacher; Jesus Christ – if you accept Him – is God. After all, would you be likely to hear the claim ‘Before Abraham was, I am’ (John 8:58) from a sane person? If Jesus had been simply a common man, or not God, then he had better pick up his grammar book, and study verb tenses properly, before uttering such nonsense.

A man who was merely a man and said the sort of things Jesus said would not be a great moral teacher. He would either be a lunatic—on a level with the man who says he is a poached egg—or else he would be the Devil of Hell. You must make your choice. Either this man was, and is, the Son of God: or else a madman or something worse. You can shut Him up for a fool, you can spit at Him and kill Him as a demon; or you can fall at His feet and call Him Lord and God. But let us not come with any patronising nonsense about His being a great human teacher. He has not left that open to us. He did not intend to. (Lewis, Mere Christianity 52)

As Lewis also observes, ‘Christianity is a statement which, if false, is of no importance, and, if true, of infinite importance. The one thing it cannot be is moderately important’ (God in the Dock). Yet, to return to Gandhi, it seems true that he may have been encouraged in his interpretations by Leo Tolstoy, whose late and unconvincing religious works he fervently admired. Like his Christian counterpart (or ‘Christian,’ because of course Tolstoy was not a Christian), Gandhi set non-violence above all other values – an idea so absurd that it is hardly worth being commented on.

In fact, this worship of non-violence, which seems to stem more (as in Tolstoy’s case) from an unadmitted disbelief in another plane of existence, and perhaps even from a great fear of death (this is, at least, certainly true of Tolstoy and his late, and at bottom solipsistic, writings, as Bloom argues), than anything else – this worship of non-violence makes Gandhi’s quoted statement and other sorts of universalism even stranger, given the fact that Mahomet, the founder of Islam, not only forced himself on a nine-year-old, but ordered the beheading of over five hundred Jews – the Jews being another group which, unsurprisingly but still absurdly, Gandhi also identifies with. Certainly I am not knowledgeable enough about the man’s religion, nor about Eastern spirituality in general – although it is not unknown to me that the Sanatan Dharma requires the alignment of one’s actions and state of being with atman, the self or soul, or rather the principle that inhabits each self and each soul. For ‘God in his transcendence and immanence is also the Spirit of man, the Self in every one and in all, Atman’ (Mascaró 12), since ‘only when man is in union with God is he in union with himself’ (25). Almost Kierkegaardian, isn’t it? All this, indeed, supports the view that there is something common to all human beings, such as an individual self or soul, a profound personal longing – which is related both to a fear of physical death and the desire to be immortal – and even an innate moral sense, which Lewis calls ‘the law of Human Nature’ (Mere Chistianity 4), and which is perfectly complemented by Solzhenitsyn’s powerful insight, that ‘the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being’ (Gulag Archipelago 75).

However, the ways different religions assert these truths and justify them vary immensely. And not only that (which I shall not get into deeply in this brief article), but we are not only spirit! As human beings, it is asked of us to live an embodied life. We inhabit, too, the material plane of existence, and though it is our job to be able to transcend it, such transcendence does not seem possible unless we immerse ourselves in reality, in history, in the works of art of our ancestors – and language itself shapes us immensely. Of course, in this, too, different religions differ in their views – another point in favour of my argument.

Those who are familiar with the things I write must by now be asking themselves when I’m going to mention T. S. Eliot. Well, the moment is come. Scruton, in his splendid essay on the poet and critic ‘as conservative mentor,’ affirms precisely this need to accept history and culture, and that only through time can we attain timelessness – ‘Only through time time is conquered’ (Eliot, ‘Burnt Norton,’ II 43). This leads us, therefore, to the dimension of memory as well, and to that of personal memory. The two coincide. We inhabit a certain environment, a particular place with its particular history, and we are formed by it, as well as by the tensions it causes (something further discussed by Eliot in his The Idea of a Christian Society and Notes towards the Definition of Culture). Few works of recent poetry or literature in general (that I am aware of) present this topic with such accuracy and aesthetic power as Tolentino Mendonça’s Introdução à pintura rupestre, where we are taken back to our religious, historical, social, and personal origins with distinct sublimity – and where macrocosm and microcosm meet in a fascinating manner.

I must note that in the discussion of one’s need for roots I am not really going against Gandhi’s notion, who knew very well that one must value his heritage and ancestry, rather than adopt another culture’s habits and customs. But the religious universalism of many nowadays is markedly different from Gandhi’s, who was a committed Hindu and embraced his culture. Without going into detail, it becomes clear that ours is a world where most people who find an appeal in Gandhi – or more generally in Eastern spiritual practices – are simply those not patient enough for deep, systematic thinking. This makes such stances more popular than ever, and is the cause of a poisoning vagueness of thought – a kind of thought so easy to reject that arguments against it become rather dull, since one side so clearly outweighs the other. But if more and more are unavailable for actual discussion, then those arguments will remain largely unnoticed, in a society which has less and less time in which to engage in serious thought. It is this that makes today’s more popular religious universalism especially dangerous, as well as other such tendencies.

All religions may contain a hint of truth – I daresay they do. But it is logically impossible for any two of them to be equally true, or equally valid paths to the same spiritual truth. As in everything else in life – for hierarchy is in the nature of all things – equality is in this case an illusion. It may be comforting to believe in it, but it is nonetheless an illusion. I would therefore like to have a few of C. S. Lewis’s words as my conclusion: ‘As in arithmetic – there is only one right answer to a sum, and all other answers are wrong; but some answers are much nearer being right than others’ (Mere Christianity 35).

Bibliography

Eliot, T. S. The Poems of T. S. Eliot: Volume 1: Collected and Uncollected Poems. Edited by Christopher Ricks and Jim McCue. Faber and Faber, 2018.

Gandhi, Mahatma. The Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi, Vol. 87. The Publication Division, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India, 1983.

Holy Bible. Authorised King James Version, William Collins, 1991.

Lewis, C. S. Mere Christianity. William Collins, 2012.

Lewis, C. S. God in the Dock. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2001.

Mendonça, Tolentino. Introdução à pintura rupestre. Assírio e Alvim, 2021.

Scruton, Roger. ‘T. S. Eliot as Conservative Mentor.’ The Imaginative Conservative, 13 Nov. 2026, T.S. Eliot as Conservative Mentor ~ The Imaginative Conservative.

Solzhenitsyn, Aleksandr. The Gulag Archipelago. Vintage Classics, 2018.

The Upanishads, translated with an introduction by Juan Mascaró. Penguin Books, 1965.

 

 

 

Partilhar Artigo:

Mais Artigos

Porque é que as elites vitorianas foram tão eficazes?

Análise sobre porque é que as elites vitorianas foram tão eficazes: como o maior império que o mundo alguma vez viu foi gerido por uma pequena elite que festejava a noite toda, bebia litros de vinho do Porto e ficava na cama até ao meio da tarde.

Qual é a frequência das falsas acusações de violação?

Em 2009, o National Sexual Violence Resource Center (NSVRC) afirmou que as falsas acusações de violação representam apenas 2–8% do total das acusações de violação. Trata-se de um valor frequentemente citado, mas será correcto? Vejamos o que dizem os estudos.

Manipulação Da Responsabilidade Ambiental: Contexto, Desdobramento E Alternativa

Investigação que analisa a eficácia das medidas de responsabilidade ambiental nos protocolos internacionais. Conclui que transferem a mitigação de emissões para o terceiro mundo via créditos de carbono, gerando “irresponsabilidade organizada”. Propõe a democracia ecológica directa em Moçambique como alternativa.

As Cinco Estirpes que Deram Origem à Nobreza de Portugal

Das cinco estirpes fundadoras da Nobreza de Portugal (Sousões, Braganções, Maia, Baião, Ribadouro), do Livro Velho de Linhagens e José Mattoso. Sobre hereditariedade (Pio XII), tradição e o conceito de estirpe como fonte vigorosa nascida na Reconquista Cristã.